Paleo Stuffed Peppers

paleo stuffed peppers 93

These babies look good. They taste even better. They are totally grain-free and the parmesan cheese I grated over the top is totally optional. But if you ask me, a stuffed pepper without shredded cheese on top ain’t no stuffed pepper.

I feel like since I didn’t include rice or quinoa then I can have a little cheese sprinkled on top. 

It’s my life.

Let’s begin. You need these items:

paleo stuffed peppers 5 Four stuffed peppers.

You don’t need to get them in assorted colors, of course. It’s cheaper to get them all green but I’m trying to make this look pretty for you guys, so I went with an assortment.

paleo stuffed peppers 16

 You also need a red onion, some garlic, asparagus, lemon and parmesan cheese, if you enjoy the good things in life.

paleo stuffed peppers 18

 Don’t forget the mushrooms and thyme! They are essential.

In terms of seasonings and spices, you need Worcestershire sauce, turmeric and red chili flakes. 

paleo stuffed peppers 19

 The porcini salt is completely optional. I am obsessed with porcini mushrooms.

So, when I saw a Wild Porcini Mushroom Sea Salt, I just about screamed and jumped up and down like I had been saved by one of those TV pastors who have those programs that come on in the middle of the night.

“I’ve been saved! Porcini salt! Hallelujah! Praise the Lord! I once was lost, but now I’m found…”

Finally, you need about 1 lb of ground beef. Below is a photo of freshly ground beef from grass-fed chuck roast. It is beyond delicious. The texture and flavor of freshly ground beef makes the pre-ground stuff seem like a punishment.

If you aren’t able to grind your own beef and you’ve only had the pre-ground stuff then just use that. You won’t know what you’re missing. I was unaware for years. But once you try it, it’s over. You can’t go back.

It’s like going black.

paleo stuffed peppers 20

 Ok so now that you have all your ingredients, time to prep them.

Begin by removing the tough ends of the asparagus. All you have to do is bend them and they will naturally snap where they are supposed to.

paleo stuffed peppers 21

Then pull the stems off the mushrooms, if you are using whole mushrooms.

paleo stuffed peppers 24

Ok, now slice the mushrooms, roughly chop the asparagus and finely dice the onion and garlic.

paleo stuffed peppers 25 paleo stuffed peppers 26

Now you have your “mise en place,” which is a French term for “everything in place”. The cooking process should go very smoothly now.

Begin by sautéing the onion first, until it has browned a bit.

paleo stuffed peppers 29

Once it browns, add the garlic and cook for just a minute:

paleo stuffed peppers 30

Then add the beef and spices.

Cook the beef till it’s totally cooked through and then make a well in the pan:

paleo stuffed peppers 31 paleo stuffed peppers 32

 Add the mushrooms to the well (I love cooking in wells, you don’t have to but it soothes my soul).

paleo stuffed peppers 33

Toss the mushrooms around in the well until they are coated in the turmeric-tinged yellow beef fat.

What a sentence.

paleo stuffed peppers 34

Once the mushrooms have slightly softened, stir them into the beef and add some Worcestershire sauce.

paleo stuffed peppers 35

Some fresh thyme:

paleo stuffed peppers 43

 And the juice of a half a lemon, or the whole lemon if that tastes better to you.

paleo stuffed peppers 44

Add the asparagus.

paleo stuffed peppers 42

 Stir and then turn off the heat. The mixture will continue to cook in the oven, so you don’t want to overcook the asparagus. I like it when asparagus still has a bit of a snap to it.

paleo stuffed peppers 47

 Preheat the oven to 400F, and drizzle a little oil on the baking dish you will be using.

paleo stuffed peppers 51

Cut the tops off the peppers and deseed them.

paleo stuffed peppers 48 paleo stuffed peppers 49

Now stuff them with the beef mixture.

paleo stuffed peppers 52

 Place the peppers upright in the baking dish you just greased.

paleo stuffed peppers 54 paleo stuffed peppers 55

Top with shredded parmesan if you love yourself.

paleo stuffed peppers 56

Side note: After stuffing four peppers I had this much of the beef mixture left over:

paleo stuffed peppers 57

I placed it in a freezer ziploc bag and popped it in the freezer. The next time I want stuffed peppers I just have to defrost the mixture and stuff the peppers. So easy!

Now the oven should be at 400F. Pop the peppers in the oven and bake for 30 mins or until the parmesan has browned to your liking and the peppers have softened.

paleo stuffed peppers 59


I didn’t bake the tops because I wanted them to retain their shape and color.

Look how pretty they are:

paleo stuffed peppers 61

I can’t decide which photo I like best.

paleo stuffed peppers 67

paleo stuffed peppers 76 paleo stuffed peppers 79

paleo stuffed peppers 90 paleo stuffed peppers 89

 I totally overloaded you with stuffed pepper pics. I can’t help it, they look so good. Almost as good as heirloom tomatoes.

Oh ya, by the way, I ran into your mom yesterday and she told me to tell you to subscribe to my blog by typing your email in the box below.

She said it’s not right to read a blog without subscribing and you know how moms are always right. I don’t agree with her, but I do think you should always listen to your mom.

So, here’s the box:


Go on and type your email above.

Live a little.

[yumprint-recipe id=’68’]